Check syntax and required fields
Review matching braces and quotes, entry types, required authors or editors, titles, years and publication fields. Required fields depend on the entry type and bibliography style. Compile the document in your usual editor to find syntax and bibliography warnings.
Compare identifiers and source records
Check DOI or ISBN values against publisher or library records. Compare title, author order, year and edition rather than treating a found DOI as proof of a correct match. Duplicate DOIs may indicate duplicate records; matching titles can also describe a preprint, later publication or different edition.
Match manuscript citation keys
Compare the keys used in your LaTeX or Pandoc files with the keys in your .bib file. Inspect included files and custom citation macros as well. Correct missing keys and review unused entries without deleting material you still need. Preserve keys when other parts of the project depend on them.
Preserve intentional formatting
Work on a copy. Preserve capitalization braces, string definitions, comments and fields that you did not intend to change. Fix duplicate keys explicitly. Keep a short record of which bibliographic values changed and which sources support the corrections.
Compile and inspect the result
After saving the bibliography, compile the complete manuscript and inspect both in-text citations and the reference list. Check the output against the publisher’s instructions. A syntax check cannot determine whether a source supports your claims or certify publication readiness.